Muhammad Daud Dedicates Song to Charly Van Houten, AI Video Sparks Controversy
Businessman Muhammad Daud released a song dedicated to singer Charly Van Houten, but the use of artificial intelligence in the music video drew criticism from fans.

Muhammad Daud has presented a song titled "Bertahan atau Pergi" (Stay or Go) to his friend, Charly Van Houten, the vocalist of the Indonesian band Setia Band, as reported by Tabloid Bintang.
The work attracted attention because its music video was created using artificial intelligence (AI). In response to criticism from some fans, Muhammad Daud apologized and emphasized that AI was merely a visual aid, not the core message of the dedication.
Cross-Profession Friendship in Entertainment
Friendships between public figures from different professional backgrounds are common in Indonesia's entertainment industry. Many prominent musicians have social circles that extend beyond music, including entrepreneurs, athletes, and officials. In this case, Charly Van Houten is widely known as a singer and songwriter who has been active on the national music stage since the era of the band ST12, before forming Setia Band. Meanwhile, Muhammad Daud built his reputation in the business sector.
This phenomenon of cross-professional friendship often leads to unique collaborations. An entrepreneur with a passion for music frequently uses their resources to create artistic works as a form of personal appreciation. Unlike commercial productions oriented toward financial profit and market targets, such dedications generally stem from emotional impulses and a desire to preserve shared memories. The song "Bertahan atau Pergi" itself carries the theme of romantic dilemma, a universal topic closely associated with the Malay pop style that has defined Charly's career.
On the other hand, the presence of AI technology in creative content production has become a global debate that has also reached Indonesia. Creating AI-based music videos allows anyone to produce cinematic-quality visuals without requiring large crews, filming locations, or high production costs. This technology works by translating text commands into sequences of moving images through generative algorithms. However, this ease clashes with aesthetic values and fan expectations, who are accustomed to seeing their idols' actual performances in conventional visual formats.
For solid fan communities like the listener base of Setia Band, the visual representation of an idol holds specific meaning. When an artist's face or vibe is reconstructed by a machine rather than shown through genuine camera footage, some audiences feel an emotional distance is lost. This is the root of the controversy, where the good intention of presenting a work collides with the visual acceptance standards of loyal fans.
AI Trends and Lessons for Local Creators
This event provides a real picture of how Indonesian society responds to the penetration of AI technology in the creative sector. For local music enthusiasts, music videos are not just audio complements but part of the experience of enjoying a musician's work. When these visual elements are entirely handled by machines, friction arises between technological innovation and market tastes that still value direct human touch.
From a policy and creative ecosystem perspective, the trend of using AI in music video production could impact behind-the-scenes workers. The local film and music video production industry involves many professionals, from directors and lighting designers to cameramen and editors. If content creators increasingly rely on generative software to cut costs, demand for professional services in these fields may shrink. This is a significant concern for creative industry players in Indonesia who depend on visual production projects for their livelihoods.
Apart from the pros and cons regarding the technology, Muhammad Daud's move shows that the space for expression in the music industry is no longer exclusive to professionals. Anyone now has access to create and distribute works. What needs to be considered going forward by creators, both amateur and professional, is the importance of reading audience expectations before releasing material involving specific public figures. Understanding the boundaries between technological experimentation and respect for an artist's image will determine whether a work is accepted as a sincere dedication or triggers unwanted controversy.
Related News
(Our newsroom has contacted those involved. This story will be updated once we receive an official response.)


